Category: Island Update

The FISH of Sanibel-Captiva organization is highlighting the deep impact of its community support services, sharing the story of an island resident who recently experienced a profound loss. After a long period of caring for her partner through poor health, the neighbor faced the heartbreaking challenge of his passing. In the difficult months that followed, FISH has stepped in to offer comfort, care, and vital connection.

Through a variety of its support programs, the resident found not just necessary aid, but a renewed sense of community and friendship:

• Meals-by-FISH: Providing prepared meals during a time of grief.
• Smile Boxes and Friendly Faces Luncheons: Offering opportunities for social connection and community engagement.

Beyond these social programs, FISH provided crucial practical assistance, helping the neighbor gain access to essential home health resources and medical equipment. She also received support from the organization’s post-hurricane aid following recent storms. Looking ahead, FISH has enrolled her as a recipient in the upcoming holiday food and gift drive.

The support offered by FISH demonstrates the power of community in helping neighbors pick up the pieces and navigate life-changing moments.

The City of Sanibel has provided an important update, announcing that the repaving of Periwinkle Way commenced today, October 23.

The project focuses on the section of Periwinkle Way extending from approximately 500 feet west of Casa Ybel Road to about one-third of a mile east of Donax Street. To minimize disruption, all milling and paving operations will occur during evening and overnight hours, with nighttime lane closures in effect between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m.

Project Paving Schedule

The city’s contractor has released the following detailed paving schedule, which is subject to change based on weather conditions:

Date	Work Description
Oct. 23	Resetting a manhole in the westbound lane of Periwinkle just west of Dixie Beach Boulevard.
Oct. 26	Paving turnouts on side streets of the westbound lane of Periwinkle from Periwinkle Park to just west of Jerry’s Foods (including Whisperwood Way, Main Street, Fitzhugh Street, Palm Street, and Dixie Beach).
Oct. 27	Paving turnouts on side streets of the eastbound lane of Periwinkle from just west of Jerry’s to Periwinkle Park (including Casa Ybel Road and Donax Street).
Oct. 28	Paving the westbound lane of Periwinkle from Periwinkle Park to the Dixie Beach intersection.
Oct. 29	Paving both westbound and eastbound lanes of Periwinkle from Dixie Beach to just west of Jerry’s.
Oct. 30	Paving the eastbound lane from Dixie Beach to Periwinkle Park.

The City assures the public that access to all residences and businesses will be maintained at all times throughout the project. Drivers are reminded to operate their vehicles slowly and cautiously through the work zones when crews are present. The contractor will utilize clear signage and flaggers to efficiently direct traffic.

For more detailed information regarding the project, citizens may contact the Public Works Department at sanpw@mysanibel.com or call 239-472-6397.

The Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation (SCCF) has announced that the official sea turtle nesting season on the islands will conclude on October 31.

The SCCF provided a final count of its successful season as of October 22, showcasing significant numbers for both species monitored:

• Loggerhead Nests: 868
• Loggerhead Hatchlings: 27,083
• Green Turtle Nests: 21
• Green Turtle Hatchlings: 607

While the season is winding down, the SCCF issued an important reminder to the public: residents and visitors must continue to turn off or shield any lights visible from the beach after 9 p.m. This practice is crucial to ensure any remaining hatchlings can safely navigate to the water without being disoriented by artificial light.

For anyone who observes issues with sea turtles or their nests on Sanibel and Captiva, the public is asked to contact the SCCF’s Sea Turtle Hotline directly at 978-728-3663.

The Sanibel Historical Museum and Village has announced a major step toward recovery following Hurricane Ian in 2022: the roof replacement project for the Rutland House has officially begun. The project was initially scheduled to commence on October 14.

As the property owner and a key village partner, the City of Sanibel is providing the funding for this essential repair. The city has selected Quick Roofing to execute the work, which will be comprehensive. The scope includes the removal and replacement of the existing metal roofing system, alongside a necessary structure retrofit and the installation of new sheathing to ensure compliance with the current building and wind codes.

The Village shared that this roof replacement represents a critical milestone. “This is the first essential repair to be completed post-Hurricane Ian before reopening the house to the public,” a representative stated.

A Look at the Rutland House

The Rutland House is a significant piece of local history. It was originally built in 1913 and stood on Periwinkle Way, just west of the current Periwinkle Park.

The structure is made of slash pine and exemplifies Cracker architecture. This distinctive style is characterized by a wood-frame structure with a low-slung roof and a prominent, wide front porch. The term “Cracker” is used to refer to the early pioneers and their descendants in Florida.

Clarence Rutland purchased the home in 1928 and resided there until his death in 1982. He was the son of Irene Rutland, who later married Henry Shanahan, the Sanibel lighthouse keeper in the early 1900s. Although Clarence and his wife, Ruth (Wiles), had no children, he was affectionately known throughout the community as “Uncle Clarence” and was celebrated as a “jack of all trades.”

Following Clarence Rutland’s passing, the building was moved to the Village in 1982. It served a vital role for many years, housing the entirety of the museum when it first opened to the public in 1984.

For those interested in learning more about the museum and its ongoing work, please visit the official website at https://sanibelmuseum.org/.

The Mucky Duck, a beloved Captiva Island restaurant, has cleared a major reconstruction hurdle and is now on a clear path to reopening. Owner Andreas Bieri is now targeting a reopening date of December 1, 2025, or by the end of the year, just in time for the peak season and the restaurant’s 50th anniversary in 2026.

The path forward was secured during a pivotal on-site meeting on October 13. Bieri, his construction contractor, and a kitchen design expert met with the Captiva Fire District to resolve a potentially critical issue with the new kitchen’s layout that could have failed a fire safety inspection.

During the meeting, kitchen range hood designer David Fusaro devised an on-the-spot solution. By reconfiguring the kitchen and moving the main cooking range to an adjacent wall, the design now fully complies with safety codes.

“As far as chances of success, we went from a ‘maybe’ to 100%,” Fusaro said, confirming the new plans will be approved.

This innovative solution comes with an unexpected benefit: the new layout will nearly double the restaurant’s cooking capacity, promising greater efficiency. “Different configuration,” Fire Chief Jeff Pawul told Bieri, “But it will give you a bigger capacity.”

The Mucky Duck, a landmark known for its sunset views, was destroyed by Hurricane Milton in October 2024 after having survived Hurricane Ian two years prior. Bieri, who has been part of the restaurant since 1980, was determined to bring it back. The building’s historic designation made a near-replica rebuild possible on its iconic beachfront location.

For Bieri, the resolution to the kitchen problem brought immense relief. “I feel better,” he said. “I have to say. I think I can sleep tonight much better.”

Get ready for a one-of-a-kind pirate adventure! Captiva Cruises is partnering with The Island Club at North Captiva to offer an exclusive sunset voyage to the Swashbuckler’s Ball on Saturday, October 25.

The Swashbuckler’s Ball is the ultimate pirate-themed celebration, running from 6 p.m. to midnight at The Island Club. Guests are encouraged to don their best pirate attire for a night filled with live music, a Caribbean buffet, bottomless beer and rum cocktails, and pirate-themed entertainment, including prize drawings and a costume contest.

For a truly unique experience, guests can book the special package with Captiva Cruises. The voyage departs from McCarthy’s Marina at 6:00 p.m. aboard the Santiva, a 45-foot catamaran. You will enjoy a scenic journey with beautiful sunset views from Captiva Pass before arriving at the party.

The Captiva Cruises package includes:

• A scenic sunset cruise (drinks available for purchase on board).
• Round-trip transportation to The Island Club on North Captiva.
• Two hours of access to the Swashbuckler’s Ball, including all food, drinks, and entertainment.

Tickets for this cruise and two-hour event experience are $100 per person. Space is strictly limited to 49 guests, so early booking is highly encouraged.

For those who wish to attend the full six-hour pirate bash, general admission tickets are available for $110 directly from The Island Club, but these do not include the sunset cruise or ferry transportation.

To book the sunset cruise package, visit CaptivaCruises.com. For more information, you can also call Captiva Cruises at 239-472-5300.

Sanibel and Captiva Islands are set to usher in the holiday season this weekend with the return of a cherished community favorite. Hosted by the SanCap Chamber, the 39th Annual Luminary Stroll will take place over two festive nights, serving as a glittering highlight to Sanibel’s 50th-anniversary celebration.

This year’s event promises to be a significant moment for the islands. According to Chamber President and CEO John Lai, over 70% of local restaurants, retailers, and accommodations have reopened.

“Our goal is to offer recognition to island businesses and encourage local shopping, while providing a fun-filled evening for family and friends,” Lai said. “We think this holiday season will kick off the most crucial visitor season that we’ve had.”

Event Schedule & Kick-Off

The festivities are free and open to the public, taking place from 4 to 9 p.m. on both nights.

• Thursday, Dec. 5: Periwinkle Way on Sanibel

• Friday, Dec. 6: Captiva Drive and Andy Rosse Lane on Captiva

The official kick-off is scheduled for Dec. 5 at 4 p.m. at Tahitian Gardens on Sanibel. Attendees can expect remarks from Sanibel Mayor Mike Miller and the island’s first mayor, Porter Goss. WINK News Chief Meteorologist Matt Devitt will also be broadcasting live from the location.

A Trail of Holiday Fun on Sanibel

On Thursday night, candle-lined pathways—set up by the Sanibel-Captiva Rotary and Kiwanis Clubs—will guide visitors to various landmarks, shopping centers, and businesses offering treats, refreshments, and entertainment.

Here is a look at what is happening along the trail:

• Tahitian Gardens: Watch for Santa and the Grinch arriving on a Harley at 5:30 p.m., along with kids’ games, door prizes, and live music. Adventures in Paradise Outfitters and Wilford & Lee Home Accents will also be offering specials and treats.

• The East End: Activities begin at the East End Shops with Santa, free hot dogs, and live music at Tuttle’s Seahorse Shell Shop. Don’t miss the roasted chestnuts at Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream—a perennial favorite.

• The Shops at Jerry’s: The local Boy Scouts will be handing out hot dogs, while visitors can enjoy caroling and photo ops with Santa.

• Heart of the Islands: MacIntosh Books + Paper and Home by Rachel Pierce will feature treats and a hot chocolate bar.

• Sanibel Community Church: A hub for families, the church will host a petting zoo, pony rides, and two performances of Handel’s “Messiah” by the Sanibel Choir and Orchestra (5:30 and 6:30 p.m.).

• Periwinkle Place: Look for special sales, free chili at Blue Giraffe Island Bar & Grill, and refreshments at Congress Jewelers and Her Sports Closet.

• Music & More: The Sanibel Music Festival kicks off at the Sanibel Congregational United Church of Christ with a concert at 4 p.m., while The Village Shops and Saint Michael and All Angels Episcopal Church will offer live music, bounce houses, and refreshments.

Captiva Celebrates on Friday

The magic continues Friday, Dec. 6 on Captiva Island. The luminary trail will guide guests from ‘Tween Waters Inn & Marina, down Andy Rosse Lane, and out to South Seas. Participating businesses will feature live music, retail specials, and holiday cheer.

Logistics & Parking

 

Sanibel Captiva Community Bank is the presenting sponsor for this year’s stroll, helping to cap off the 50th-anniversary year.

Parking for the Sanibel event (Dec. 5) is available at:

• Olde Sanibel Shoppes

• Periwinkle Place Shops

• Tahitian Gardens

• The Community House

• The Shops at Jerry’s

Maps will be available at the Chamber’s Visitor Center (1159 Causeway Blvd) and at sponsor locations.

With more retailers and restaurants open than in the past two years, this weekend offers the perfect opportunity to support the local island economy while enjoying the holiday spirit.

If You Go:

• What: 39th Annual Luminary Stroll

• When: Dec. 5 (Sanibel) & Dec. 6 (Captiva) | 4 to 9 p.m.

• Cost: Free and open to the public

• More Info: Visit sanibel-captiva.org/luminary

A significant milestone in Captiva’s recovery was marked on October 15, as owner Sandy Stilwell Youngquist and her team held a groundbreaking ceremony for the new Captiva Island Inn. The beloved property, which was largely destroyed by Hurricane Ian, is beginning a $6 million rebuilding project designed to be more resilient while honoring its historic charm.

The decision to rebuild follows a difficult period after the storm. Stilwell Youngquist, who has owned the inn since 1999, described the devastation as heartbreaking and the choice to demolish the original wood-frame structures as an emotional one.

“When we got to the island after Hurricane Ian and saw the devastation, it was heartbreaking,” Stilwell Youngquist said. “And I’m getting choked up, because that’s how hard it was, to realize we had to tear it down.”

Managed by Stevens Construction with a design by MHK Architecture, the project will restore the inn’s capacity, adding 10 new units across two new buildings for a total of 15 units.

The new design thoughtfully balances modern resiliency with the inn’s historical character. After consulting with the Lee County Historic Preservation Board, architect Carmella Cioffi of MHK Architecture developed a plan that pays homage to the original cottages.

“They required that the new design harken to the old design,” Cioffi explained. “We kept some detailing from the original building — decorative trim, the window styles and the colors, and we incorporated those into the new buildings.”

Stilwell Youngquist plans to bring back the original cottage names and will use five different types of siding to ensure the new buildings retain the “quaint, island look” of separate cottages.

The project is a significant investment in the island’s future, especially as the local economy continues to feel the effects of the storm. “Our economy has really dipped down for tourism,” Stilwell Youngquist noted, expressing hope that recovery and rebuilding efforts will encourage visitors to return.

Construction is expected to take about a year, with a target opening date in late fall 2026. In another sign of progress, Stilwell Youngquist’s ice cream and coffee shop, Latte Da, is on track to reopen on November 1.

The action in the Co-Ed Adult Slow-Pitch Softball League continued this week, with a full schedule of games on the evening of Wednesday, October 15. Teams gathered at the Sanibel Ballfields, located at the Sanibel Recreation Center, for three competitive matchups.

The evening’s schedule featured the following games:

• Bubble Room vs. No-See-Um’s at 6:20 p.m.
• Whitney’s Bait and Tackle vs. The Locals at 7:25 p.m.
• Children’s Education Center of the Islands vs. Traders at 8:30 p.m.

As the season progresses, teams are looking ahead to the season-ending tournament, which is tentatively scheduled for December 17.

The Captiva Island Fire Control District commission has directed staff to proceed with a potential purchase of bayside parcels from the Rauschenberg property, a move aimed at expanding and consolidating the district’s services for the future.

During their October 7 meeting, Fire Chief Jeff Pawul and Commissioner Jeff Brown presented findings from their due diligence on acquiring land for a new fire station, which could include a helicopter landing zone and a boat dock.

Commissioners reviewed several options with significant price tags. The main debate centered on two choices: a $23 million option that would split operations across Captiva Drive, or a more expensive $29 million option to acquire approximately 9.8 acres on the bayside, keeping all facilities unified.

While acknowledging the high cost, the commission recognized the unique and fleeting nature of the opportunity. “If this 10 acres sells, it’s going to be developed,” Chief Pawul stated, emphasizing the land’s strategic value.

Commissioner Sherrill Sims called the bayside parcels “perfect” for the district’s current and future needs, adding, “There’s not going to be another chance… You’ve got to go for an opportunity like this.”

Ultimately, the commission unanimously agreed to pursue the more comprehensive bayside option to keep all operations together. The next step is for staff to finalize the financial details of the proposal, which will then be presented to the community for a vote. Any potential purchase is contingent on voter approval through a ballot referendum.

“Then see if the community supports it,” Pawul said.

In Other News

• New Hires: The district has filled two of its three new positions. Firefighter-EMTs Mason Kennington, a recent graduate who previously worked in radiology, and Douglas Leuge, a former firefighter from Kentucky, are expected to begin soon. The district will test again to fill the final open position.
• Policy Updates: The commission voted 3-0 to approve updates to the district’s administrative policies.
• September Report: The district responded to 22 incidents and conducted 23 fire inspections during the month of September.