Urban Renewal With Purpose: $1M Acquisition to Transform Fort Myers Bike Shop into Motley Market

A purposeful revitalization project is underway with Motley Market Fort Myers Cleveland Avenue, breathing new life into a prominent midtown commercial corridor. On August 31, 2026, local commercial real estate broker Dan O’Berski—managing partner at Trinity Commercial Group (TCG)—finalized the $1 million acquisition of the 4,200-square-foot former bike shop at 3630 Cleveland Avenue under the corporate entity Cleveland Hill LLC.

Instead of developing a conventional strip retail store or fast-food drive-through, the building is being transformed into Motley Market Fort Myers Cleveland Avenue, an eclectic farmers market, neighborhood general store, and cross-cultural community gathering place.

At the LeAneSuarezGroup, we actively monitor commercial investments, adaptive reuse projects, and urban infill redevelopments across Southwest Florida. Transforming historic properties into thriving gathering hubs enhances walkable neighborhood amenities, encourages local foot traffic, and drives long-term value for nearby residential communities.

From Legacy Cycling Anchor to Motley Market Fort Myers Cleveland Avenue

Located at the northwest corner of Cleveland Avenue (U.S. 41) and Hill Avenue, the building served as an active bicycle shop for more than three decades. It first operated as Fort Myers Schwinn, followed by a 28-year run as Fort Myers Cyclery under Michael and Diane Holm, before being acquired in September 2023 for $815,000 by 3630 Cleveland Ave LLC, owned by Edward Wian and operated by his son, Michael Wian.

With the Wians moving their retail operations east to Centerplace at Esplanade off Alico Road, the site is embarking on an entirely new chapter. Even so, the location will honor its two-wheeled heritage: the team behind Motley Market Fort Myers Cleveland Avenue intends to sell refurbished, discounted electric bicycles alongside fresh food to encourage sustainable local mobility.

                  PROPERTY ACQUISITION TIMELINE
  
  [ 1990s–2023 ] ──► Operated as Fort Myers Schwinn / Fort Myers Cyclery
  [ SEPT. 2023 ] ──► Acquired by 3630 Cleveland Ave LLC ($815,000)
  [ AUG. 31, 2026]──► Purchased by Dan O’Berski / Cleveland Hill LLC ($1,000,000)
  [ 2026–2027 ]  ──► Redevelopment into Motley Market Farmers Market & General Store

The Mission & Community Vision for Motley Market

O’Berski funded the acquisition using equity from his ownership share in the $65 million summer sale of The Pointe at Founder’s Square in North Naples. Facing a tight timeline to execute a traditional 1031 tax-deferred exchange, O’Berski opted to deploy the capital directly into this community-oriented urban revitalization venture.

The facility will be leased to For Prophet, a dedicated non-profit organization founded by O’Berski, which will manage operations, oversee vendor relationships, and direct outreach initiatives:

• Farm-to-Table Pipeline: Sourced directly from a 10-acre agricultural farm O’Berski placed under contract, scheduled to close this fall, ensuring a continuous supply of seasonal fruits, vegetables, and greens.

• Essential General Store: Supplying daily grocery staples, household pantry essentials, baked items, and refurbished e-bikes.

• Civic Gathering Space: Serving as an inclusive neighborhood meeting ground across from Latimer Crossing, a 92-unit mixed-income apartment community whose retail space recently welcomed Foxtail Coffee.

• Food Truck Activation: An on-site food truck will be activated on the property to provide food and beverage options while the main structure undergoes renovation.

                 REDEVELOPMENT TARGET BENCHMARKS
  
  [ LATE 2026 ]   ──► Complete interior buildout & layout modifications
  [ FALL 2026 ]   ──► Finalize purchase of 10-acre supporting produce farm
  [ EARLY 2027 ]  ──► Exterior CRA façade enhancements & site modifications
  [ MARCH 1, 2027]──► Targeted grand opening for Motley Market general store

To assist with streetscape improvements and exterior façade restoration along U.S. 41, O’Berski is preparing an application for municipal grant funding through the Fort Myers Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA).

Redefining Urban Connectivity & Neighborly Culture

For O’Berski—a long-time resident of nearby Jefferson Park who leads an in-home faith group known as L1A (“Love One Another”)—the decision to open across from an adult entertainment venue is an intentional choice rooted in community-first values.

The name “Motley” reflects its dictionary definition: incongruously varied in appearance or character; disparate. The ultimate vision for Motley Market Fort Myers Cleveland Avenue is to bring together families, business professionals, and residents from diverse backgrounds, fostering connection across the neighborhood.